Get the lowest rate for your Hotel in Tuscany through Booking.com

Get the best deal direct from the owners on TuscanyAccommodation.com

Book your unique Tuscan Experience

Book your Tour

Book your Tickets ahead & Skip the line!

Buy Museum Tickets

Renting a Villa in Tuscany?

Top 10 Things You Need to Know as You Select a Villa to avoid disappointment upon arrival

With over 20 years of experience in representing villas, visiting vacation homes and writing reviews about holiday rentals in Tuscany, I am going to share some insight on the things you should be asking when you start to search for your perfect holiday base in Tuscany.

Using an old adage - the only bad question is the one that went unasked - I have compiled a list of 10 things you need to be clear on when choosing your home away from home.

1. Know your vocabulary

To be clear, property owners do not set out to “trick” their guests. They really want their guests to be happy. Happy guests write happy reviews! But sometimes they don't always offer enough information on the site about their accommodations or things get lost in translation. And then there are those who apply a bit of a poetic license when they define their accommodations as a “villa” and not simply as a holiday home.

Normally, the word villa evokes a stately manor or a prestigious antique building, however, the term vacation villa or villa rental can refer to any structure (new or old) that is independent of another connecting structure. I've seen the term villa much more loosely used by websites/agencies with origin in the US who use it as a marketing selling term than local ones, who do pay careful attention to what they call themselves.

Clarify with the owner that this is the case and there are no other structures/buildings sharing space with you if you're interested in renting an entire property for yourself.

2. Villa or Apartments

Once you have established if it is a villa on the outside, you need to enquire about how it is organized internally. Is it one villa or a villa divided up and composed of connecting apartments?

I suggest that there is no good or worse answer here. In fact, combined apartments can provide extra privacy for large groups traveling together, especially when you are families with small children or the guests are not exceptionally familiar with everyone else. But if you are looking for a large kitchen and dining rooms suited for the entire group, then you might find that apartments won't always be able to offer the same feel as one large villa and they can also take away from the “group living as one” sensation.

Before you look, know how you and your group want to live and expereience your villa rental in Tuscany.

Private Tuscan villa rental with pool and great views

3. Neighbors

There is no way around it, photos can be deceiving. If your privacy is important then don’t be afraid to ask how close your nearest neighbors are to you. I have seen enough villas to know that you can rent an “independent villa” but still have neighbors right across from your front door.

4. Your “go-to” Person

In most cases, you will never need to make contact for an emergency during your stay, but in the odd chance that the electricity goes out, the hot water disappears or the refrigerator stops running, then you are going to want help... and quickly. Know before you go if there is a caretaker on-site and, if not, just how far away are they from the property?

The larger villas will often have a caretaker on-site available 24/7 for your assistance, they will know about local restaurants, shops and markets and they can help you with questions about planning your itineraries.

5. Extra Services

Extra services are almost always paid separately and not included in the rental price, but they can be the tipping point when selecting one villa over another.

Some of the extras that can make a difference: Is there a chef on hand? Bikes? A spa area with hot tub and sauna? Assistance with arranging tickets to museums, taxis and tours? Especially helpful is showing up to your villa rental and knowing it is already fully stocked with food, or if not, do they offer a welcome basket? And a personal favorite, I like knowing that there is maid service to clean up, after all, you are on vacation.

Spas services, chef and cleaning services are extras at a Tuscan villa rental

6. References

One of the great things about the internet is the wealth of information online, it is virtually impossible that someone hasn’t thought to write a review about the villa rental you are looking at. Villa rental owners are constantly trying to make their offer competitive and up to date, so they make changes every season, therefore remember to look at the date of the review so that you know it is current. In addition, don't be put off immediately by negative comments: if someone mentions a lack of towels, poor internet service, lumpy mattresses or not enough garden chairs, then ask the owner if they have "fixed" the situation. It is likely not a problem anymore!

A word of caution, independent reviews can still be biased and not completely representative of an accommodation and its services…. don’t be swayed by just one review. Look for several comments and, as an added precaution, ask for references directly from the owner.

7. What’s Included

Nothing will make you feel more cheated then arriving on site and the reception starts to tell you what isn’t included in the price. Yes, they have a washing machine, but it costs 5 Euros a load. Yes, there is air conditioning, but there is a supplement in the cost if you turn it on. Or yes, there is a fireplace, but the wood is extra.

Villa owners will often put it on their website but sometimes it gets overlooked and seems like yet another unexpected cost: the local tourist tax. Perhaps what bothers guests the most is that the owner requires you to pay this tax on site (and in cash). But the tax is actually real and it needs a separate receipt which is why they don't include it in the price of the villa.

One that is also often overlooked is the final cleaning fee. This is not always included in the price of the villa but you'll find it added on at the end of your stay.

Moral of the story: ask if the price you've found or have been quoted is all-inclusive (and get what is included and isn't in writing).

Tuscan villa rentals include historic homes & Tuscan farmhouses

8. Looking for the Best Deal

It is an unavoidable fact, agencies have commission fees, that’s how they make their living. When a villa owner has to pay out commissions, they don’t have a lot of room for a discount. But if you go direct to the owner, you will find that sometimes you can save up to 30%.

If your dates are flexible, then you can look at renting in mid or low season which often has a great price break and the added plus of visiting Tuscany in the off season (less congestion at the tourist destinations like museums, monuments and restaurants). The pricing seasons also change from owner to owner. One owner might include June in high season and another might not - look at this carefully as this could save you lots on rental fees.

9. Book Direct with Owner

Worried about fraud? Heard horror stories about arriving and there was no villa?

It is always best to start your search on villa rental sites that send you direct to the owner to book and that has a reputation for being clear and open. You might wonder what makes these sites different from others, and why do they send you direct to the owner for the reservation? Because they normally work with a flat advertising fee… and not on commissions.

Another way to avoid problems is to look for signs in the Tuscan villa rental descriptions that the website has visited the property; normally, you will note unique photos and text, personal observations and helpful hints about the property. Another way to safeguard yourself is by checking for official reviews. Yes, these can be sponsored articles, but it is also proof that the villa is a real business.

10. Pick your Dates

Just because the "booking" site says your desired dates are not available does not mean that the dates are 100% unavailable, it just means they are not available on that booking site. Sometimes owners will block select dates so they have more control over their calendars and their rentals.

If you really like the accommodations, then go directly to the owner and ask. If the dates are taken, sometimes they could put you on a waiting list if the prior booking for those dates are not yet confirmed. By going direct, you manage to access this possibility, something that an online booking site or agency might not offer.

Panoramic views from your Tuscan villa rental

Are you ready to start looking for your villa? Start your search on TuscanyAccommodation.com which offers reviews of top villas and sends you direct to the villa's official website.


Author: Donna Scharnagl

It has been over 24 years since I took my first steps in Italy and I still haven’t found a good reason to leave.  Between the food, the culture, the history, the art, the landscapes … did I mention the food? I have become a lifelong student. And I soon learned that Italians all have stories that long to be told; stories that paint a picture of how hard work produces character, how life is made of ups and downs and how good it feels to laugh.



Comments

Questions? The right place to ask is our Forum*

* Questions posted on Comments above will no longer receive replies: please ask on our Forum!

Our Travel Guides

  • DiscoverTuscany.com
  • VisitFlorence.com
  • Chianti.com
  • Tuscany Accommodation.com
  • Florence Accommodation.com